“The
distinction between “higher” and “lower” systems in the brain offers no relief:
as the conscious witness of my experience, I no more initiate events in my
prefrontal cortex than I cause my heart to beat. There will always be some
delay between the first neurophysiological events that kindle my next conscious
thought and the thought itself. And even if there weren’t— even if all mental
states were truly coincident with their underlying brain states— I cannot decide
what I will next think or intend until a thought or intention arises. What will
my next mental state be? I do not know— it just happens. Where is the freedom
in that?” Harris,
Sam (2012-03-06). Free Will (p. 9). Simon & Schuster, Inc.
What will your next ‘thought’ be? You have no ‘idea’ until
you think it and what comes up will be influenced entirely by the variables of the
moment, such as external stimuli, and your response to those variables will be
determined by genetic and socio-cultural programming, all of which you have no
control over. In fact, neuroscience is studying how
trauma, experienced by your
ancestors (parents, grandparents, etc) has genetically shaped your current day
neuroses.
It is true that you are a unique little snowflake, but “you”
were shaped by preceding events and factors that had to occur to make your
existence an actuality. The core ‘self’ is genetically hard-wired in your brain
and any changes made are a product of already formed circuitry and, thus, were
entirely predetermined. The fact that you quit smoking exactly when you did was
preceded by numerous influential factors that shaped that decision right up to
the moment it was made.
You struggle mightily against a predetermined causal order
in an attempt to wrest some crumbs of control from an indifferent, but
infinitely unfolding, universe. Sometimes it seems you have succeeded, only to
look back and find that all your failures and successes were pre-scheduled as part of
a preordained causal order that began long before you existed, but made your
existence possible.
Egocentric ‘control’ is different from the control found in
the rest of the natural order. While a lion must control his thinking to
acquire an antelope, in order to assuage his instinctual requirements, egocentrica
mammalia demands control of his “thoughts” because, as opposed to the
instinctual influences evident in the entire natural world, he believes he has
free-will over what he thinks and this is his chief delusion and cause of all
his suffering.
A lion is certainly in control of his thinking, as he
concentrates on the antelope selected for dinner, but this is entirely
influenced by the instinctual need to eat and the factual food before him. Hence
we cannot say that the lion ‘controls’ his thinking, but that programmed
instincts and external conditions specifically control what is thought, when
and why, allowing the lion no free-will to think anything other than what is
demanded in the moment. His reality is purely factual and there are no
fictional considerations for which to concern his thought processes. He need
not concern himself with fictional realities, such as what “clothes” to wear
for dinner or whether there is enough “money” available to purchase his dinner,
because there are no fictional realities involved in filling his belly with
food. He has no ‘self’ for which to make fictional preferences as to what
antelope he might devour since clearly he will eat the exact one he can most
easily catch.
Human egocentrica mammalia thinks that he chooses his thoughts.
However, if this were factual, shouldn’t he always ‘think’ only the most
advantageous thoughts he could ‘choose’? Why is egocentrica mammalia so fooking
miserable? If he can choose his thoughts, why is he then not immensely “happy”
every moment of his life, regardless of external conditions? If he can choose each and every thought in his head,
why not choose only the most positive and “happy” thoughts? If he can choose a
thought before thinking it, why would he choose a thought that causes him to
suffer? If he could choose what to think, why think a thoughts that causes
anger, anxiety or depression? Why is it so hard for egocentrica mammalians to
be “happy” if, in fact, they are in control of their thinking?
The answer is obvious...
Instead, he often thinks thoughts that he would rather not
think, but feels compelled nevertheless, because of the suffering those thoughts entail.
This demonstrates that he has no free-will to choose his thoughts, because his
thinking is entirely owned by the fictional and factual realities of a
predetermined causal order that determine his “thoughts” for him and every one
of those thoughts are wired up in the circuitry between his ears. Egocentrica
mammalian thought processes are often so disparaging and dreadful that he turns
to drink and drugs to anesthetize the electro-chemical impulses (thoughts)
coursing through his grey matter. An entire fictional world, referred to as
“entertainment,” needed to be constructed as a means of distracting him from
his own neuro-circuit impulses.
Just like the lion, egocentrica mammalia cannot “think”
outside his neuro-circuits and the external conditions that determine which
circuits fire up in response to those conditions, thereby, provoking actions
and behaviors that the “self” claims are chosen volitionally. This demands that
he generate more circuits through a process of “education” which allows him to
construct ever more complex fictional realities through which to control his body
and his personal world as a means of continually actualizing as fact his
fictional ‘self.’ The lion has no fictional ‘self’ wired up in his noggin and,
thus, must only give attention to the factual needs of the body. The lion cares
not if his thoughts are positive or negative, good or bad, right or wrong. He
has no choice in his thinking and moves with the predetermined causal order as that
order directs him.
Egocentrica is controlled by his fictional realities,
demanding he find ever more ingenious methods to escape that control and thus
be in control of the predetermined causal order. “Crime” is a fictional reality
that seeks to circumvent fictional “laws” and actualize a fictional ‘self’
outside the predominant fictional realities of the fictionalized social order.
But the criminal is as much victim to the fictional realities as those who
reverently adhere to the fictional laws. Fictional realities of the social
order determine what you ‘think’ and you have never had a choice in that and
nor do you have a choice in when you will think what you think as external
conditions will prompt conditioned programmed responses to be exactly as they
must.
You did not create the fictional realities that currently demand
your participation and that give fictional meaning to your factual life by
determining how and what to think. I imagine that most people, if they had a
choice, would not participate in half the silly social games they now feel
compelled to engage with. Fictional realities were thrust upon you with absolutely
no choice as to when, where or why. The education and learning of fictional
realities packed tightly in your cranium makes all the choices for you based on
programmed circuitry that you had no personal responsibility in developing.
The essential fictions were programmed into your head and
you now automatically respond from that programming. As much as you try to
control your fate, it has already been predetermined, unless of course, the
predetermined causal order removes you completely, but you have no choice in
that either.
All this may sound fairly bleak; however, for some it could
result in a ‘surrender’ to the WILL of a predetermined causal order, but only
if the circuits take you there, since it is electro-chemical impulses within
fatty tissue that makes choices and not “you.” There is no “you” in there and
there never was.
Essentially, a sense of dread and defeatism is often
experienced with the realization that every ‘choice’ ever made had to be made
exactly as it was, which will inevitably lead to other choices being made
exactly has they have to be made. Your ‘life’ is exactly how it should be in
this moment based on all the moments that brought you to this moment, because
you are always ‘in the moment,’ regardless of how you evaluate what is
happening in that moment (also predetermined) and each moment is completely
influenced by the moment preceding. You will still make ‘choices,’ but you can
rest assured that any choice you make had to be made, regardless of your
evaluating it as ‘good’ or ‘bad’ after making it. You cannot act any
differently than you do act in any moment, as each moment shapes the context of
the next since the very moment the universe first came into being.
There is no reason to feel guilt for actions as all actions
happen as they must or they would have happened differently. You may claim that
you should have acted differently than you did in any moment, but if you could
have acted other than you did, and “you” are in control of your thinking, why
did you not choose thoughts that allowed for a different action? What is
actually occurring is that you’re simply responding on auto-pilot to external
stimuli in ways you have been socio-culturally programmed to respond. There was
no volitional ‘choice’ involved at all. Actions impacted upon the grey matter
years ago, in turn, determine behaviors occurring in this very moment, just as
this very moment conditions the brain for future moments.
You are on a path not of your making, but that path has been
unfolding long before you were even born.
Although you are certainly making decisions that provide
direction, the decisions are merely programmed responses to external events,
both of which are outside your control. You cannot understand the ‘purpose’ of
the path you are on because it is interwoven with a trillion other purposes
that were predetermined to be followed before you were born to be who you are,
that had to be made for you to be who you are, and your path is interwoven with
other paths that must be followed simply as a result of your manifesting and
being who you are. Make no mistake, entire civilizations had to fall, world
wars needed to be waged and millions had to live and die exactly as they did for you to
be in this moment right now.
Whether saint or sinner, your only purpose is to go where
the circuits take you and you will do that, because you cannot exit from that
path because “you” did not choose it, but it was determined for you long before
you existed. However, you can live in a state of surprise, in which little
control is necessary and you ride the causal waves without predicting or
preparing for what unfolds before you. Or not... depending on the circuitry.
Since you have no idea what your next thought will be, there
is little need to worry about the future. Unless, of course, that just happens
to be your next ‘thought.’ But that’s okay too, since it had to arise exactly
as it did, exactly when it did and, hence, there is no need to fret about it unless,
of course, you’re wired up to fret about it in the moment you do, which is
exactly what was supposed to happen as it obviously did or else it would not
have happened exactly as it did.
The predetermined causal waves you ride each and every
moment have been occurring long before you came on the scene and will continue
long after the worms have completely devoured your rotting carcass. Your actual
freedom is defined by the complete absence of free-will in the recognition that
your life will unfold exactly as predetermined. There is nothing you need do
about it, because there is nothing you can do, but watch it happen exactly as
it must and how you evaluate each moment is as much destined to be a part of
the next moment as the previous moment’s actually occurring exactly as it did.
Based on circuited responses wired up in your brain, you
will either joyously ride the predetermined causal waves or suffer through
years of madly swimming for some fictionally safe shoreline. Either way, the
choice has never been yours to make, but it will always strangely seem that some
nebulous shadowy “I-me” experience is ‘choosing’ to madly pump out ‘thoughts’
within a calcium shell and making choices based on its own free-will. This will
seem real until the time comes that it recognizes it has never made a choice
that was not part of predetermined causal order outside its control, but that
it has never been separate from. In the universal ‘oneness’ of an unfolding
causal order, every choice made was predetermined to be made long before the
experience of making it had occurred.
Your WILL has never been your own.